SAT Vocabulary 1.1: Should I read a lot or memorize?

Believe it or not, the answer has something to do with compound interest (hence the photograph).
Reading is unquestionably the best, most important, and most effective way to learn vocabulary.
The entire question becomes somewhat simpler when you realize one major principle: memorizing words produces a linear increase in vocabulary, whereas reading lots of books produces a cubic or even exponential increase in vocabulary.
In other words, reading gives you compound returns on the time that you spend. That's it. That one rule alone makes all of these patterns clear.
That's why memorizing works better in the short term, and reading works better in the long term.
Why? Well, it should be obvious why memorizing words produces a linear increase in vocabulary. You're just adding words at a more or less constant rate. (Actually, this is an oversimplification: you do become much faster at memorizing words over time. But still, the effect is nothing like the cumulative effect of reading.)
Reading produces a cubic or exponential gain in vocabulary for at least two main reasons:
1) As you read, you become a faster reader--even three to four times as fast over time. That means you're exposed to three to four times as many words. So reading a lot not only helps you learn words, it triples or quadruples the rate at which it's possible for you to learn words. Get it?
2) As you read a lot, you become a better reader, which makes reading more fun, which makes it much more likely that you will occasionally read for pleasure, or at least be able to finish all of your assigned reading for school without cutting any corners. This means that you are not only learning more words per hour, you are also learning words for more hours in the day.
These observations show what educational scientists and researchers have also suggested:
In his studies of first graders, Allington (1984) found that the total number of words read during a week of school reading sessions ranged from a low 16 for one child who was classified as a poor reader to a high of 1,933 for a child classified as a good reader. Commenting on these findings, Stanovich (1986) noted: “The average skilled reader reads approximately three times as many words in the group reading sessions as the average less skilled reader” (p. 380). Similarly, Nagy and Anderson (1984) estimated that
the less able and motivated children in the middle grades might read 100,000 words a year while the average children at this level might read 1,000,000. The figure for the voracious middle grade reader might be 10,000,000 or even as high as 50,000,000. If these guesses are anywhere near the mark, there are staggering individual differences in the volume of language experience, and, therefore, opportunity to learn new words. (p. 328).
There's a lot else that goes in to it but I'm getting boring, I know, so I'll stop.
Understanding this simple principle--that memorizing words produces a linear increase in vocabulary, whereas reading lots of books produces a cubic or even exponential increase in vocabulary--makes a lot of other stuff clear. 
Take a look at the generic graph of linear vs. cubic growth above. (This is not a graph of actual vocab acquisition rates; it's just a visual aid.) Let's take the x-axis to be the amount of time you invest, and the y-axis to be the number of words you know. The red line illustrates the rate at which you can learn words through memorization. The green line is the (approximate) rate at which you can learn words by reading. When you're not very far out on the x-axis (like if you have only a few days or weeks to learn words), you might be better off memorizing, at least as far as vocab acquisition goes. But before too long, the green line starts to *skyrocket*. That's why you need to get on the reading train, even if you are a nonnative speaker.
This exponential growth curve explains how it’s possible for some students to know extremely difficult SAT words like “machinations” and “gibbering” without memorizing anything. These words are, respectively, the 32,802nd and the 42,728th most common words in current English (according to data from the British National Corpus).
Michele Hernandez, one of the most successful college counselors in the country by some measures, has this to say about vocabulary and SAT scores:
Every time I have seen a student with an 800 Verbal score, there has been confirmation through the application that the student is a reader—teachers mention it, the student often talks about loving literature from a young age and reading a lot throughout middle school and high school, and guidance counselors allude to it. No amount of test-taking preparation can earn you an 800 verbal score, because that requires a lifetime devoted to reading (Hernandez 157).
I have encountered students online recently who say that they have gotten perfect 800’s without being lifelong readers, but I have never met any in person. Tom Fischgrund’s survey of perfect-scoring SAT students found that they spent an average of 9 hours a week reading for school and 5 hours a week reading for pleasure, compared to an average of 5 hours a week reading for school and 4 hours reading for pleasure.
In the short term, memorization has a valuable, even essential, role to play in vocabulary acquisition. It usually beats out reading—just as a linear growth will usually beat out an exponential equation in the short term.
In the long term, though, reading consistently will produce a vocabulary gain many, many times larger than vocabulary memorization alone.
Some of this post is taken from one of my own earlier posts on the College Confidential forum.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home