Tuesday, January 20, 2009

A Must-Read Article from Gladwell on Teaching


This piece is classic Malcolm Gladwell: thought-provoking and highly entertaining, if also somewhat reductive. Very much worth a read.

Gladwell also has a follow-up post on his blog that fills out the picture somewhat.

Both posts remind me very much of an article called "Deep Smarts" that I read years ago in the Harvard Business Review, one that (I thought) stated the basic problems and possibilities of student teaching than anything I've read since. Apparently the article has also become (had already become?) a book, one that is receiving excellent reviews on Amazon. Here's a summary of the concept from one of the Customer Reviews at Amazon:

"The authors defined 'deep smarts' as accumulated knowledge, know-how, and intuition gained from extensive experience. Deep smarts are more than competence, but 'the ability to comprehend complex, interactive relationships and make swift, expert decisions based on that system level of comprehension but also the ability, when necessary, to dive into the component parts of that system and understand the details.' These individuals have capabilities that those with less expertise do not have, allowing them to interpret small variations in data that elude novices, make decisions quickly, or know when they are encountering a rare event and evaluate its possible outcomes quickly. This level of expertise often requires ten years to develop and [those who possess such 'smarts'] get results that novices and those who are merely expert cannot."

While this book focuses particularly on how to pass on expertise that has been acquired through experience, my hunch is that the authors' observations might also help us understand how to pass on other kinds of expertise: for instance, how to help mediocre teachers acquire the same faculty for expert judgment that gifted teachers seem to possess naturally. The description of deep smarts given above certainly resonates with the Gladwell article and also seems to describe the competencies that differentiates effective teachers from their ineffective colleagues: great teachers certainly "comprehend complex, interactive relationships"; they "make swift, expert decisions"; they possess the "ability, when necessary, to dive into component parts of [a system of relationships] and understand details"; they "interpret small variations in data"; they "make decisions quickly": and they "know when they are encountering a rare event."

Another connection: The steps described in this book (for helping novice workers grow into expert workers) sound much like what I've heard about mentoring young readers, and I'm curious about whether the book would shed any light on the Gradual Release of Responsibility model, the best way I've learned to teach complex skills in the language arts, and one that essentially codifies the process that the best teachers often employ naturally (or so it seems to me). Put differently: not only teaching, but also reading and writing, seem to require "deep smarts." I wonder whether Leonard and Swap's book might shed some light on this particular pedagogical problem.

If I find the $20 for it, I'll write a follow up!

P.S. More from the "Deep Smarts" article: "Raw brainpower, emotional intelligence, and intuition are often part of the mix, but the essence of deep smarts is a knack for combining big picture thinking with technical or managerial knowledge." To me, that's great teaching in a nutshell: combining big picture thinking (say, sensible long-range course objectives) with technical knowledge (say, the nuts and bolts of pedagogy).

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home