What a Great Way to Construct a Senior Thesis Project
One of the odd perks of my job as an ESL teacher and a literacy specialist is that I get a birds' eye view of a lot of other people's course planning. Yesterday at work, for instance, in addition to running a large number of scanning drills, giving my seventeen-year-old students hell for not learning words, and spending two hours scouring the Internet for a strong anthology of fiction for elementary-aged children (suggestions, anyone?), I got glimpses into several really interestingly planned literature classes that several of my ESL students are taking at school. One local tenth-grade teacher is presenting Alexander Pope's "Essay on Man" alongside Frankenstein, a pairing that got my brain working. I also had a chance to discuss, at some length, the problem of just how to deliver a poem that you've memorized, which is a really interesting question and one that in some ways I think you never really outgrow.
Perhaps the highlight of my Saturday, however, was a chance to observe the unfolding of a really excellently planned series of twelfth-grade English assignments, ones leading progressively toward a senior thesis. I've never seen a senior thesis project so sensibly progressive, so developmentally appropriate, and so (in my opinion) consistent with the best practices of English criticism as a discipline. Like most of the really great curriculum design I've encountered in the last five years, it was also deceptively simple.
The first thing I loved about this assignment is that it taught the student to place the works of literature in the context of other, directly relevant primary texts, instead of either reading the work in a vacuum (a common approach) or asking the student to rely on secondary sources for context (also common). The teacher allowed the students to choose their own topic but required them to focus on a single major author (say, Fitzgerald) and read several works of literature by that author (say, The Great Gatsby, This Side of Paradise, The Beautiful and Damned, and Tender Is the Night, as well as perhaps some stories and essays).
In my opinion, this requirement represented a great course planning decision both because it was very appropriate for high school seniors and because it reflects the way that the best critics and readers proceed. In a couple of cases, while a grateful guest in Harvard's GSAS program, I heard a couple of truly world-class scholars spell out their approach to close reading and contextualizing primary sources. In both cases, the scholar began by a close reading of the text itself, and then began by placing the text in the context of other works by the same author, then in works of the same period. This procedure tends to be carried out very deliberately in the fields of both history and English, and in many ways, it's a very obvious progression, one that's far more central to the humanities as they are practiced at the highest levels than is the reading of secondary sources (about Fitzgerald the Jazz Age, for instance). But we rarely pass it on to young students. Requiring high school seniors to read several novels by one author as part of a capstone project is a deceptively simple way to pass on a truly critical reading skill.
What's more, it's a very appropriate to the twelfth-grade classroom because it requires students to accomplish a novel and unfamiliar task, but it allows them to employ very familiar skills in the process. In my opinion, this type of apparently effortless building on past mastery is a hallmark of great curriculum development.
Other things I have liked about the assignment as I have watched it unfold, over my own student's shoulder, as it were:
1. It begins with the familiar (writing several essays on individual novels) and moves progressively and predictably into unfamiliar territory. This sounds as obvious as the rest of it, but so often teachers will suddenly jump into the deep end: you've been writing three- to five- page papers about specific topics, and now you can write a ten-page paper using extensive secondary sources on a topic you've never encountered before in your life. Too much novelty! Too much!
2. The teacher dealt directly with new tasks instead of relying on students to pick them up through immersion. She named them ("now we will learn to synthesize our analysis of individual works,") she defined them ("here is what it means to synthesize our analysis of individual works,") she introduced them gradually into her progression of assignments ("now we will start to synthesize, which we will be doing more and more"). I will assume that she also provided models and constructive feedback regarding the new task, though I didn't have a chance to observe her doing so. As a result of this directness, she both made it easier for her students to pick up the new way of doing things and also helped them to develop metacognition, a fancy word for readerly self-awareness. Finally, she helped those students without an obvious gift for literary analysis keep pace with the rest of the students (the problem with purely immersion-based learning is that the rich tend to get richer and the poor, poorer).
Again, this activity sounds so simple that you may wonder why it made me smile so much (which it did). The reason is very simply that it's so often missing from high school courses. Very often, less able teachers will expect students to pick up a new skill by immersion, setting a course pace that will allow most students do so successfully. They will, for instance, assign the students' first 10-pager without ever directly addressing the multitude of individual tasks that a 10-page paper requires and that the 6-page paper does not. A 10-page paper, for instance, can often benefit from an entire section of background information or context that would be out of place in a 5-page paper. Likewise, a 10-page paper often requires a much narrower topic than a 6-page paper, but most students, left to their own devices, will choose a much broader topic for their first long paper than they choose for their shorter papers. Successful high school teachers often identify as many of these issues as possible in advance and address them with the students directly.
It's always a pleasure to see one of my own students working directly with a very able classroom teacher, and I always learn a lot from observing such expert syllabi and assignments when they pass through my own classroom. Classes like that one make up for all of the unteaching that I occasionally have to do (no, Beowulf is not an allegory about the seven deadly sins; no, Emily Dickinson was not sleeping with Henry David Thoreau!).

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home