Thursday, February 19, 2009

Making Inferences

The process of teaching students to make inferences is often one of the most daunting challenges that parents and inexperienced teachers face. In the past, I've given some general tips and also sent people toward texts on the subject. The skills text More Reading Power has a helpful chapter on inferences and another on thinking in English. The book I Read It, But I Don't Get It is an even better hands-on guide to the cognitive steps required of students as they learn to make inferences for the first time.

The author of I Read It, But I Don't Get It makes the excellent point that the metaphor of "reading between the lines" is a fairly useless one when it comes to helping children understand what's really required of them. I've also heard parents tell children, in exasperation, that the answer to an inference question is "common sense." Perhaps a better metaphor than "reading between the lines" is "connecting the dots": I like to tell students that their job is to look at a lot of details or facts from the text and find their connections, and that as they do so, a familiar, coherent picture will eventually begin to emerge. Sometimes, students make connections between or among parts of the book; sometimes they may connect the book with their background knowledge (the "common sense" that parents invoke). One can often help a struggling student by spelling out these steps in detail. This metaphor is particularly useful in helping students understand the difference between making inferences and simple guessing: we can "guess" what shapes a Connect-the-Dots handout contains as well, by staring at it and suggesting random possibilities, but we're unlikely to find the answer very quickly. (And of course, the way that we connect dots in literary studies is most commonly by rereading.)

Inferences are frequently born as answers to our own questions. Any question we have about the text is an opportunity to make an inference about that text. The problem is that many students, especially those who are insecure, experience questions as confusion rather than as curiosity. Recently, in my classroom, I've been trying to get students to stop using the word "confusing" and instead use the word "ambiguous" (as in, this text has two or more possible meanings). My goal in doing so has been to get kids away from the essentially negative "confusing" (which implies that the text lacks meaning) and toward the more neutral "ambiguous" (which implies that the text is overdetermined). Today, in class, I wrote on the board, "1. Confusion. 2. Ambiguity. 3. Inference." Often, it seems to me, those are the steps that we want to encourage young readers to take: to move from a feeling of confusion to a conscious recognition of the several possible meanings that may be at work in the text (whether or not they are all valid), and from that point, to begin relating the possible meanings to the rest of the text in order to validate or invalidate them.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home